Use code MOM50 at checkout thru Mother’s Day to get 50% off any gift card for marketing services
- +1 512-591-8295
- [email protected]
- Mon - Fri 9:00 - 16:00
Use code MOM50 at checkout thru Mother’s Day to get 50% off any gift card for marketing services
You know you need marketing help. The harder question is figuring out what kind.
Do you need a Fractional CMO? A marketing agency? A marketing consultant? Someone who can actually implement the work?
The answer isn’t as simple as “strategy versus execution.” Fractional CMOs can consult. They can also implement. Consultants may help execute their recommendations. Agencies can provide excellent strategic guidance in addition to performing the work.
The better question is: What do you need someone to be responsible for? Do you need more people to perform marketing work? Expertise to help solve a particular problem? Or someone with senior-level experience taking responsibility for the direction of your marketing as a whole?
That’s the distinction that matters.
A Fractional CMO provides senior marketing leadership without requiring you to hire a full-time Chief Marketing Officer.
Their primary responsibility is usually the bigger picture: determining priorities, connecting marketing decisions to business goals, overseeing budgets and resources, coordinating different areas of marketing, evaluating results, and making sure all those individual pieces are actually working together.
Depending on the engagement, a Fractional CMO might:
The title describes the level of marketing leadership you’re bringing into the business, not the limits of what that person can do.
This is also an area where Fractional CMOs can differ significantly.
My background isn’t limited to sitting at the strategy level. I have decades of hands-on experience across specialized areas of marketing, so I can move between the CMO-level view and the work happening underneath it.
Sometimes I’m developing the strategy and directing your existing team or agencies. Sometimes I’m consulting on a specialized marketing problem. Sometimes I’m personally involved in implementation, or my team handles it. Often, it’s a combination.
That means we don’t have to force your business into an artificial choice between someone who can determine what should happen and someone who knows how to actually make it happen.
If you’re trying to determine whether your business has reached the point where it needs this level of leadership, start with how to know when you need a Fractional CMO.
A marketing agency is generally hired to provide execution capacity, specialized expertise, or both. That might include:
Agencies can be extremely valuable when you know what needs to be done but don’t have the internal people or expertise to do it. And good agencies should provide strategy within their areas of expertise. An SEO agency shouldn’t blindly execute a keyword list you hand them. A PPC agency should make strategic recommendations about campaigns. A branding agency should understand your audience and positioning before designing anything.
The distinction is that an agency is typically responsible primarily for the marketing work within its scope.
The potential problem comes when nobody is responsible for the spaces between those scopes.
Your SEO company may be doing good SEO. Your advertising company may be running competent campaigns. Your social media person may be producing exactly what you asked for.
That’s where marketing leadership becomes different from marketing execution.
A marketing consultant is generally brought in for expertise, analysis, advice or problem-solving.
You might hire a consultant because you need help with:
Consulting can be a one-time engagement, a defined project, or an ongoing relationship.
And consultant doesn’t automatically mean “advice only.”
I provide marketing consulting, and depending on what a client needs, that engagement may end with recommendations, continue into implementation, or evolve into ongoing strategic support.
The important question isn’t whether someone uses the word consultant. It’s what they’re actually being hired to accomplish and what responsibility they’re assuming for the outcome.
The simplest distinction is:
An agency is generally hired to provide marketing services. A Fractional CMO is generally hired to lead the marketing function.
That doesn’t make one better than the other.
In fact, you may need both.
A Fractional CMO can make a good agency more valuable because the agency receives clearer strategic direction, priorities and context.
Instead of the business owner trying to coordinate several specialists and translate business goals into marketing instructions, the CMO can work directly with those resources and make sure their work supports the larger strategy.
I’ve frequently worked alongside existing agencies, consultants, SEO companies, developers, advertising providers and other specialists. My objective isn’t to step on their toes or replace people who are doing good work.
It’s to make sure the right work is being done for the right reasons.
That’s one of the major benefits of outsourcing your marketing leadership to a Fractional CMO, particularly when you already have capable people handling execution.
This distinction can be much blurrier because Fractional CMOs frequently provide consulting. A consultant is generally hired because you need their expertise on a particular issue, opportunity or area. A Fractional CMO typically assumes broader responsibility for marketing leadership.
For example, you might hire a consultant to determine why your lead generation has declined and recommend what should change.
You might hire a Fractional CMO to continually oversee lead generation, positioning, budget, vendors, campaigns, measurement and the other marketing decisions affecting growth.
But these aren’t rigid boxes.
I can work with a business as a consultant on one specific challenge without becoming its Fractional CMO. I can also serve as its Fractional CMO and personally consult on or implement individual pieces of the strategy.
The difference is the scope of responsibility the business needs me to assume.
This is one of the most important distinctions to make before you hire anyone.
If you already know exactly what needs to happen and simply don’t have enough capacity to execute it, hiring an agency, specialist, employee or VA may solve the problem.
But hiring another person to execute marketing doesn’t solve a strategy problem.
I’ve seen business owners start by hiring the least expensive execution resource they can find and then expect that person to determine what the marketing strategy should be.
That puts responsibility in the wrong place.
A VA may be excellent at creating graphics, scheduling social media, formatting emails or handling other marketing tasks. That doesn’t automatically mean they should be responsible for determining your positioning, selecting your marketing channels, deciding how your budget should be allocated or identifying which activities will actually support your growth goals.
The same principle can apply to specialists and agencies. Being excellent at executing one area of marketing doesn’t automatically make someone responsible for deciding how the entire marketing operation should work.
I’ve gone deeper into this problem in when to choose strategic marketing help versus hiring a Virtual Assistant.
The order matters:
Determine what should be done, then make sure you have the right resources to do it.
An agency may be the better fit when:
A Fractional CMO may be the better fit when:
And you may need both if you need senior marketing leadership plus execution capacity.
That’s often the strongest combination rather than an either/or decision.
A consultant may make more sense when the problem is relatively defined.
You have a specific question, decision, project or problem and need experienced outside expertise to help solve it.
A Fractional CMO makes more sense when the need extends beyond one problem and someone needs to assume broader, often ongoing responsibility for marketing direction.
For example, you might hire a consultant to help determine why a particular service isn’t selling.
You might hire a Fractional CMO when that question is connected to larger issues involving your positioning, audience, pricing, lead generation, sales process, marketing budget and overall growth strategy.
Sometimes you don’t know how large the problem actually is until someone experienced starts looking at it.
That’s also why I offer both consulting and Fractional CMO support. Not every business needs me sitting in the CMO seat. Sometimes you need an experienced outside perspective to solve one problem and then you’re perfectly capable of moving forward.
Then implementation should be part of the conversation when you’re evaluating your options.
Don’t assume that hiring a Fractional CMO means you’ll receive a strategy document and then be left to figure out how to make everything happen yourself. Ask:
This is also one of the differences in how I work.
I’m not a CMO whose experience stops at the strategy level. I’ve spent decades actually working across the specialized areas that make up a marketing strategy, from branding and messaging to websites, SEO, content, email, advertising, social media and the systems connecting them.
So depending on what your business needs, I can operate at several levels:
That flexibility matters because your needs may change. You shouldn’t necessarily have to find a new marketing resource every time the problem moves from “What should we do?” to “How should we do it?” to “Who is going to get it done?”
The goal isn’t for me to own every piece of your marketing. It’s for the right person to handle each piece, with all of it working toward the same strategy.
Strategic planning with a Fractional CMO goes deeper into what that leadership and planning role can look like.
Don’t automatically assume you need to fire the agency. Sometimes the agency is the problem. Sometimes it isn’t.
The agency may be doing exactly what you hired it to do, but nobody is providing the larger strategic leadership necessary to make its work successful.
Or you may have multiple providers doing individually reasonable work that doesn’t add up to a cohesive marketing strategy.
That’s a different problem from simply hiring the wrong agency.
A Fractional CMO can work directly with your existing agency or vendors, evaluate what’s happening, ask the questions you may not know to ask, connect their work to the broader strategy, and help determine whether you need better direction, a change in scope, additional resources, or a different provider.
I’ve covered that situation separately in Can a Fractional CMO Help If My Marketing Agency Isn’t Working?
Start with the problem you’re actually trying to solve.
If you have good strategic leadership but need people to execute, an agency may be exactly what you need.
If you need experienced advice around a defined marketing problem, a consultant may be the best fit.
If the larger issue is that nobody is taking responsibility for the direction, priorities and coordination of your marketing as a whole, that’s where a Fractional CMO becomes particularly valuable.
And if you need a combination of those things, don’t assume you have to choose only one. That’s deliberately how I’ve built my own Fractional CMO and consulting work. I can provide the executive-level strategy, consult deeply in specialized areas, work with the marketing resources you already have, and step into implementation when that’s the best use of my expertise.
Your business doesn’t fit neatly into amy one service-provider box. The marketing support you hire shouldn’t force it into one.
If you’re considering Fractional CMO support, you can explore my Fractional CMO services and see how I approach strategy, leadership, consulting and implementation.
As Seen In
