Use code MOM50 at checkout thru Mother’s Day to get 50% off any gift card for marketing services
Most entrepreneurs pour their energy into getting people to buy. They adjust pricing, polish their websites, obsess over funnels and conversions — and miss the real reason people become, and stay, loyal customers.
The businesses that build real traction don’t just sell things. They invite their audience to be something.
When customers see your brand as part of their identity, the decision stops being about price or features. It becomes emotional, even tribal. They aren’t making a purchase; they’re affirming who they are.
In buy mode, people think rationally. They compare options, calculate savings, and look for logical justification. The relationship is transactional.
In be mode, people act emotionally. They’re driven by belonging, aspiration, and self-image — the same psychology that fuels movements and lifelong loyalty.
That’s why an identity-based message like “Be the kind of entrepreneur who leads with strategy” will always outperform “Buy this marketing course.” The first connects to their future self; the second just lists a product.
I saw how powerful this psychological concept was in my early nonprofit career. One thing I learned quickly is that people choose to give with their heart, then justify their decision with their head. That’s how I quickly increased donations and giving tenfold, by honing in on what the psychology was behind donor gift choices. The same psychological concept is behind Be vs Buy … “being” is internal, emotional, heart; “buy” is logical, thought, head.
This shift is also how AI-driven search is evolving. Algorithms answer questions instantly, which means generic “Buy Now” content is increasingly invisible. But identity-driven content — the kind that builds trust, emotion, and belonging — gets referenced, quoted, and surfaced because it resonates on a human level.
“Buy” is easier to measure. You can track clicks, run reports, and justify ROI with clean data. But belonging doesn’t fit neatly into analytics.
That’s why most entrepreneurs talk about features instead of transformation. They explain what people get, not who they become.
The problem is that “buy” messaging creates quick wins and fast churn. Customers might purchase once, but they don’t stay attached. “Be” marketing creates emotional lock-in. It moves someone from buyer to believer — and believers build movements.
Let’s look at how some of the most powerful brands on the planet use this psychology to dominate their markets.
Nike doesn’t sell shoes; it sells identity.
Just do it is an anthem for personal transformation. Their marketing celebrates perseverance and inner strength, not product specs. Even their apps (Run Club, Training Club) give users a community to belong to, not just a product to use.
You don’t buy Nike — you become the athlete who wears Nike.
That’s why price rarely matters. Their audience is buying who they believe they are when they lace up those shoes.
Starbucks isn’t about caffeine. It’s about lifestyle.
They sell the identity of someone who values connection, consistency, and a certain kind of calm productivity.
Their loyalty program rewards frequency, sure — but the real hook is status and belonging.
You don’t just drink coffee there; you belong there. You know the special code to order a special drink.
Their brand created a global tribe of people who say, “This is my Starbucks,” like it’s a personal space. That’s “Be” energy.
No one buys a Harley for transportation efficiency.
They buy the freedom, the brotherhood, the story.
Their Harley Owners Group (H.O.G.) is a living embodiment of belonging — rallies, rides, patches, rituals.
The bike is the entry ticket.
The identity — the feeling of rebellion, independence, and power — is what they actually buy into.
You buy any motorcycle. But once you “become” a Harley rider, you never un-become one.
Lululemon’s entire ecosystem — from yoga events to mindfulness ambassadors — says one thing: Be the kind of person who takes care of your mind and body.
You’re not buying leggings. You’re adopting a lifestyle.
They even build in-store experiences that reinforce belonging: sweat, breathe, repeat.
They don’t market to shoppers. They speak to the community of doers.
That’s why people proudly wear the logo like a badge of alignment.
LEGO turned plastic bricks into a global movement. It doesn’t sell toys; it sells imagination. Its online communities, creator programs, and fan events celebrate the builder identity.
Fans proudly call themselves LEGO enthusiasts — not customers. They collaborate, share, and co-create new designs, deepening loyalty through participation and ownership.
I’m old AF and I still buy Legos, and receive them as gifts, and have several Lego builds on my shelf. Yet I never find myself buying kits from any knockoff competitors.
The North Face doesn’t market jackets; it markets adventure. Its entire brand voice says, “We are explorers.” Their XPLR Pass loyalty program gives customers access to experiences, not just discounts. Think about how powerful THAT is.
People who wear The North Face aren’t simply dressed for the outdoors — they identify as the kind of people who seek challenge and discovery.
Reframe your language.
Stop telling customers what to buy and start inviting them into who they want to become. Instead of “Buy our planner,” try “Be the kind of professional who never misses a deadline.” Instead of “Book your next haircut,” try “Be the person whose confidence walks into the room first.” Your audience should see themselves in your message — not your product.
Anchor your offers in transformation.
Focus on the result, not the transaction. People don’t want another course, package, or product. They want to be someone who’s more capable, confident, or fulfilled. When you describe what they’ll become — rather than what they’ll get — your offer becomes emotionally magnetic.
Build community touchpoints.
Create spaces, experiences, or rituals that make customers feel part of something bigger. A skincare brand can celebrate “the glow-getters.” A local gym can host “member milestones.” A consulting firm can create client roundtables where entrepreneurs share wins. People crave belonging more than perks.
Use your CTAs as identity triggers.
Replace flat phrases like “Sign up” or “Learn more” with action that reinforces self-image: “Step into your next level,” “Join other leaders in motion,” or “Be part of what’s next.” The goal is to make every click feel like a commitment to themselves, not a commitment to your checkout page.
Highlight your audience’s future self.
Every brand promise should paint a picture of who your customers are becoming. They’re not buying software — they’re becoming the kind of business that runs smoother. They’re not buying coaching — they’re becoming the kind of person who finally executes on their ideas. When your copy reflects the person they aspire to be, your marketing instantly feels personal and powerful.
When you market to identity instead of transaction, everything changes. Your clients self-select. They’ll tell you, “This feels like me,” instead of “How much does it cost?” They’ll renew, refer, and defend your brand because it reflects who they are.
Pricing resistance drops. Word-of-mouth rises. And your brand’s search visibility improves because AI models pull forward the content that shows emotional intelligence, authenticity, and belonging.
That’s not theory — it’s psychology.
When you help your audience be, they don’t just buy once.
They stay.
They belong.
And they bring others with them.
Because every “buy” decision fades, but when someone decides to be something — that’s permanent.
Leverage AI tools to create consistent and engaging content effortlessly.
Enhance your marketing strategy with clear, actionable phrasing.
Collaborate effectively with your team using a unified brand communication guide.
Ready for a Smarter Way to Grow?
Ever feel like your marketing should be working better than it is? You’re not alone—and you’re not stuck.
Most businesses are working hard—but still missing the right strategic support.
Step into The Unscrewed Room—where growth-minded entrepreneurs get expert insights, no-fluff tools, and real guidance.
As Seen In
